Jobs in the film industry in Michigan fell nearly 10 percent, despite the state giving away millions of dollars of tax money in subsidies to movie makers, according to the Detroit Free Press.
Fiscal Policy Analyst James Hohman said the subsidy program is expected to cost taxpayers $155 million in fiscal 2010.
The LM-2 forms for 2009 are up on the Department of Labor website. Let’s look at some of the highlights. Up first, the United Auto Workers. It was a tough year all around for the crew at Solidarity House:
We'll have comments on more union financial reports over the coming days.
Rick Lowe of the Nassau Institute posted a blog entry April 3 about his experience with a group gathered near his home in the Bahamas to watch and discuss Michael Moore's latest film, "Capitalism: A Love Story."
Moore actually called into this group to say hello and talk about the importance of voting. In the exchange he fielded a question from Lowe in which Moore perhaps inadvertently made an argument about the insidious nature of government business subsidy programs, in particular ones like the Michigan Film Incentive program.
Another study was released this month showing that teacher professional development programs are no guarantor of higher student achievement. The research compared middle school math teachers who were enrolled in an intensive professional development program with teachers who were not and found that students of teachers receiving the extra training failed to perform any better than students of teachers in the control group. This same method was employed by a study a few years ago that found professional development to be just as inept at raising student reading scores.
Interesting snippet from Saturday’s Flint Journal: Democratic Attorney General candidate David Leyton, campaigning at the Democratic state convention in Detroit, felt the need to address A Certain Labor Law Reform That Supposedly Has No Chance of Ever Becoming Law Here. According to the Journal’s Kristin Longley, Leyton drew cheers by pledging to “work to make sure Michigan never becomes a right-to-work state.”[*]
With a secondary-offense only provision, I would be agnostic on the ban and not view it as per se unreasonable in the way of seatbelt or motorcycle helmet mandates, which infringe on my right to wrack my own body as I see fit (but not others').
So I asked my Mackinac Center colleagues whether I have turned into a squish on nanny-statism. The consensus was that pro or con, in the form originally adopted by the House, this probably is not a hill for limited government defenders to die on. Some responses from Mackinac Center policy staffers:
It has been two years since Michigan's film subsidy program became law, which is sufficient for it to have gotten off the ground and had some measureable impact on the state's economy.
According to the most recent Bureau of Labor Statistics, as of September 2009 (the most recent month available[*]), there were fewer people employed by the film industry in Michigan than before the subsidy program began.
The shell corporation created by Gov. Jennifer Granholm's administration and labor allies to shanghai 40,000 home-based day care providers into a union has "no authority to set rates or provide benefits," according to the Detroit Free Press.
Some $3.7 million in "dues" is taken from small-business owners who operate day cares in their homes. The money comes out of subsidy checks the contractors receive from the state on behalf of low-income parents who hire home-based child care operators while they work or attend school.
As mentioned in a related article published in Michigan Capitol Confidential ("Analysis: What's Next for Michigan Tea Parties?" April 20), although Tea Party rallies held across the state and nation last week had mixed results in turnout, the movement itself appears strong, according to recent polls, including a Rasmussen one showing that 24 percent of U.S. voters now say they consider themselves a part of the Tea Party movement, and 40 percent have a favorable view of it.
In his latest contribution to The Detroit News editorial page, Teamsters General President James Hoffa claims the title of “defender of the middle class” on behalf of the union movement. One wonders why he bothered — aside from that, the article is devoid of content, lacking even the raw anger of a class-warfare broadside. Seriously, who is this middle class? How exactly does the union movement fight for them? By shooting down modest reforms to our public schools? Concocting clever schemes for sucking money out of the state treasury? Questionable lawsuits? Even more questionable grievances?
Yesterday marked the 15th anniversary of the creation of the Michigan Economic Growth Authority, a business-tax credit and subsidy program designed to create new and keep existing jobs in the state. The Mackinac Center has published two rigorous analyses of MEGA: "MEGA: A Retrospective Assessment" in 2005, and "Michigan Economic Development Corporation: A Review and Analysis" in 2009.
Attracting residential and commercial expansion to the Detroit Region Aerotropolis — some 60,000 mostly vacant acres between the Detroit Metro and Willow Run airports — should occur using private money, according to one Mackinac Center analyst.
"Metro Detroit already has an 'aerotropolis,' and one that was born largely of the marketplace," Mike LaFaive, director of the Morey Fiscal Policy Initiative, told The Detroit News. "The area has many logistics businesses, a major international airport, customs brokerages and air freight forwarders. We'd love to see them grow, but at what cost will this come to Michigan taxpayers?"
Schools around Michigan are cutting services and reducing staff, yet teachers in more than half of the districts statewide pay nothing toward the cost of their own health insurance.
"But the MEA has a chance to be a little magnanimous here, to show some leadership in the vein of sacrifice. Instead of standing by watching school districts gut critical services to kids, why not offer at least to soften the blow by accepting more realistic health plans? In most districts, even a 5% or 10% contribution from teachers (still well below what private-sector folks are used to) could make a big difference," columnist Stephen Henderson points out in the Detroit Free Press.
Last Week Detroit News Editorial Page Editor Nolan Finley blogged about an article that Mackinac Center senior legislative analyst Jack McHugh wrote for Michigan Capitol Confidential about how government employee unions were using their political power to prevent the Legislature from passing modest pension and compensation reforms needed to address a $1.5 billion budget deficit. It cited, and Finley quoted, three examples from before the Legislature's recent two-week spring break. They were:
Every week MichiganVotes.org sends a report to newspapers and TV stations showing how just the state legislators in each publication's service area voted on the most important and/or interesting bills and amendments of the past seven days. The version shown here instead contains a link to the complete roll call tally in either the House or Senate. To find out who your state Senator is and how to contact him or her go here; for state Representatives go here.
School districts that refuse to make available online their checkbook registers are being taken to task.
An editorial in The Grand Rapids Press said hold-out districts have the "wrong attitude" and should embrace transparency "at a time when citizens are rightfully vigilant about their money."
A state legislator recently praised the Mackinac Center for its efforts to "hold the MEDC accountable."
Sen. Nancy Cassis, R-Novi, in an Op-Ed in the Observer & Eccentric newspaper chain, praised the efforts of Center analysts to "remain focused on achieving meaningful reforms" for the Michigan Economic Development Corp.
Nearly every aspect of a teacher's job falls under the rules of a union contract. The following is an analysis of the current collective bargaining agreement for teachers and a few other employee groups in Farmington Public Schools. The district employs about 890 teachers and enrolls 11,900 students. Of its $158 million operating budget (excluding capital and debt services expenditures), about 67 percent goes towards paying employees covered by this contract.
Once upon a time a band named Pink Floyd was a fixture on the Billboard album chart. For 741 weeks, the band's "Dark Side of the Moon" reigned as one of the top-200 selling albums in the United States. The album's themes range from mortality to madness.
Today is April 15, the last day to file your 2009 tax return. Protests are happening around the state alleging rampant growth of government, overtaxation and overregulation.
Here are some facts about taxes in Michigan.
As of fiscal 2009, the State of Michigan received $23.3 billion in revenue from state taxes.
Teacher contracts are coming under greater scrutiny as Gov. Jennifer Granholm and the Michigan Legislature continue to create overspending crises that mean fewer dollars going to public schools.
"Most people probably don't have a good idea of what the pay and benefits of school employees are," Jack McHugh, senior legislative analyst, told WLNS-TV6 in Lansing.
A recent Macomb Daily editorial agrees with the point made a month ago by a Mackinac Center scholar regarding proposed legislation to cap teacher and superintendent salaries.
Mike Van Beek, director of education policy, wrote in March that benefits, not salaries, is where public school spending is most out of line compared to the private sector. Other areas where public schools could reduce overspending, Van Beek noted, include privatizing non-core support services, repealing the state's prevailing wage law that forces schools to spend an additional $250 million a year on construction, and embracing schools-of-choice.
A Wall Street Journal Op-Ed by Mackinac Center scholar Burton Folsom Jr. and his wife Anita was the most e-mailed commentary on the paper's Web site Monday.
Titled "Did FDR End the Depression?" the piece takes from Folsom's recent book, "New Deal or Raw Deal: How FDR's Economic Legacy Has Damaged America," and corrects the commonly held myth that President Roosevelt's policies brought an end to the Great Depression.
More home-based day care providers are speaking out about being forced into a union they didn't know existed and did not vote for, according to The Oakland Press.
The Mackinac Center Legal Foundation's lawsuit against the Michigan Department of Human Services over the illegal unionization of about 40,000 day care owners has moved to the Michigan Supreme Court, while the National Federation of Independent Business has filed an amicus brief in support of the Center's case. The National Right to Work Legal Defense Foundation has filed a separate class action suit in the matter against Gov. Jennifer Granholm.
The odds of a local municipality in Michigan passing a tax increase in the current economic climate are fairly low, according to Michael LaFaive, director of the Morey Fiscal Policy Initiative.
"This is the wrong time to reach deeper into American pockets," he told The Bay City Times. "It will only remind voters of the new class warfare - government employees vs. those who pay their bills."
