Superintendent, Teacher Pay

Senate Bill 1148, introduced recently by Sen. Bruce Patterson, R-Canton, would limit the total compensation of public school superintendents to 75 percent of what the governor is paid and prohibit districts from paying any teacher more than what a state legislator makes.

That works out to a cap of $132,750 a year in salary and benefits for superintendents (75 percent of the governor's $177,000 annual salary), and a $79,650 maximum annual salary for teachers. The bill uses the base pay of legislators and does not include the additional $12,000 a year they receive for expenses. There are 551 districts in the state, but SB1148 does not indicate how many would be affected by such a change to superitendent compensation. 

As The Holland Sentinel and Lansing State Journal pointed out, the Center estimates about 73 percent of public school spending goes toward employee salaries and benefits. It's unclear how much the state could save by capping teacher salaries since the Michigan Department of Education reports that average salaries in districts range anywhere from $86,000 (Gross Pointe) to $35,000 (Mid Peninsula). What is clear though is that capping superintendent compensation will have little effect on school budgets. Of all Michigan public school expenditures in 2007-2008, less than 1 percent went to pay superintendent salaries and benefits, according to the National Center for Education Statistics.

If the Legislature really wants to take a hard look at school spending, it may want to start with benefits. Center analysts estimate the state could save $451 million per year by using consumer-driven health plans with health savings accounts for school employees. Other ways schools can save a larger amount of money include privatizing non-core support services, repealing the state's prevailing wage law that forces schools to spend an additional $250 million a year on construction, and embracing schools-of-choice.

Permission to reprint this blog post in whole or in part is hereby granted, provided that the author (or authors) and the Mackinac Center for Public Policy are properly cited.